top of page
  • Writer's pictureSean Flanagan

Vacuuming Victory: Comparing Automatic & Manual Pool Cleaners for Your Pool Maintenance Needs

One of the most crucial aspects of pool maintenance is keeping it clean. A variety of debris, from leaves to insects, algae to dust, can accumulate in your pool and affect its cleanliness, functionality, and overall appearance. Pool cleaners are an essential tool in combatting this debris, but the question remains: should you opt for a manual or automatic pool cleaner? Let's compare the two, highlighting their pros, cons, costs, and maintenance requirements to help you make the best decision for your pool.

pool vacuum, pool cleaner, robotic pool cleaners, robotic pool vacuum cleaner, robotic pool cleaner, automatic pool vacuum, above ground pool, pool's filtration system

Keep Your Pool Clean & Maintained


Manual Pool Cleaners

Manual pool cleaners, often called pool vacuums, are handheld devices that require your direct involvement and physical effort to clean the pool.


  • Cost-Effective: Manual pool cleaners are typically less expensive upfront than their automatic counterparts, making them a budget-friendly option.

  • Detailed Cleaning: With a manual cleaner, you have direct control, allowing you to pay extra attention to problem areas that automatic cleaners might miss.

  • No Additional Energy Costs: Manual cleaners don't require electricity or any other power source, saving you on energy costs.


  • Time-Consuming: Manual cleaning can be labor-intensive and time-consuming, especially for larger pools.

  • Physical Effort: Using a manual cleaner requires physical effort, which can be tiring and impractical for some pool owners.


Manual pool cleaners require occasional maintenance, which primarily involves checking and replacing the vacuum bag and ensuring the hoses are in good condition.

Automatic Pool Cleaners

Automatic pool cleaners come in three main types: suction-side, pressure-side, and robotic. These units automate the cleaning process, requiring less hands-on time from you.


  • Convenience: Automatic cleaners save you time and labor. Just set it up, turn it on, and it does the work for you.

  • Consistent Cleaning: Automatic cleaners are consistent in their cleaning patterns, ensuring no spots are missed during each cycle.

  • Advanced Features: Some automatic cleaners come with advanced features such as programmable cleaning cycles, remote control, and smart home integration.


  • Higher Initial Cost: Automatic pool cleaners come with a higher upfront cost than manual cleaners.

  • Energy Consumption: While robotic cleaners are generally energy-efficient, suction-side and pressure-side cleaners can increase energy usage.

  • Possible Additional Equipment: Some automatic cleaners, particularly suction-side and pressure-side models, may require an additional booster pump, increasing the overall cost.


Automatic pool cleaners need regular maintenance to keep them running efficiently. This includes cleaning the filter bag or cartridge, checking and replacing wearable parts like wheels and belts, and for non-robotic models, maintaining the booster pump.

Cost Comparison

Manual pool cleaners are the clear winner in terms of upfront costs, ranging from $20 for basic models to around $200 for professional-grade equipment. However, the additional time and physical labor involved may be a cost in itself for many busy homeowners.

On the other hand, automatic pool cleaners range from around $400 for basic suction-side models to over $1,000 for high-end robotic cleaners. Despite the higher upfront cost, the time and labor savings may make this a worthy investment for many pool owners.

Choosing the Best Pool Cleaner for Your Needs

When selecting between a manual or automatic pool cleaner, consider your budget, the size of your pool, your physical ability, and the time you're able to devote to pool maintenance. If you enjoy hands-on maintenance and have a tighter budget, a manual cleaner might be the way to go. If you're seeking convenience, have a larger pool, or physically cannot or do not wish to manually clean, an automatic cleaner could be your best choice.

Remember, clean pools are healthy pools. Whether you opt for a manual or automatic cleaner, keeping your pool free from debris will not only make it more enjoyable but also extend its lifespan, saving you time and money in the long run. With the right pool cleaner in your corner, you can ensure a sparkling, inviting pool ready for enjoyment at any time.

Does your pool need repairs? We're here to help! 


Sea Breeze Pools services the following locations in Greater Central Florida:


bottom of page